Story Point
The Importance of Managing Work in Progress (WIP)
29 April 2018
The following example illustrates the importance of managing work in progress (WIP). While the scenarios pertain to a Scrum project, the point applies to other types of projects—such as Kanban and SAFe—as well.
Take a look at the results at the end of a sprint on a Scrum project. There are two scenarios. Both have the same user stories with the same story points for each:
- User story 1: 13 story points
- User story 2: 8 story points
- User story 3: 3 story points
- User story 4: 5 story points
- User story 5: 1 story point
- User story 6: 3 story points
- User story 7: 1 story point
Scenario A
Here are some details on A:
- User story 1: 70 hours of work performed, 5 hours of work remaining
- User story 2: 51 hours of work performed, no work remaining (and it meets the Definition of Done [DoD])
- User story 3: 45 hours of work performed, 13 hours of work remaining
- User story 4: 29 hours of work performed, no work remaining (and it meets the DoD)
- User story 5: 3 hours of work performed, 2 hours of work remaining
- User story 6: 30 hours of work performed, 17 hours of work remaining
- User story 7: 4 hours of work performed, 1 hour of work remaining
A is summarized as:
- 232 hours of work was performed, and 38 hours of work remains
- 2 user stories were done, and 5 user stories were not completed
Scenario B
Here are some details on B:
- User story 1: 75 hours of work performed, no work remaining (and it meets the DoD)
- User story 2: 51 hours of work performed, no work remaining (and it meets the DoD)
- User story 3: 58 hours of work performed, no work remaining (and it meets the DoD)
- User story 4: 29 hours of work performed, no work remaining (and it meets the DoD)
- User story 5: 5 hours of work performed, no work remaining (and it meets the DoD)
- User story 6: 14 hours of work performed, 33 hours of work remaining
- User story 5: no work performed, and five hours of work remaining
B is summarized as:
- 232 hours of work was performed, and 38 hours of work remains
- 5 user stories were done, and 2 user stories were not completed
What Counts
Scrum requires teams to build an increment of functionality during every sprint. Only work meeting the Definition of Done (DoD) is counted as complete, demonstrated at the sprint review meeting, and is potentially shippable.
There were two scenarios. Both had the same user stories with the same story points for each, and the same amount of work hours performed. Yet the outcomes were dramatically different. In A, 2 user stories were done--and are to be demonstrated at the sprint review meeting, and are potentially shippable. In B, 5 user stories were done--and are to be demonstrated at the sprint review meeting, and are potentially shippable. B is the better scenario.
A possible explanation for the differences between the two situations is that the Scrum team in B may have done a better job of limiting Work in Progress.
To learn more about agile/Scrum, check out the award-winning book, Agile Scrum: Your Quick Start Guide with Step-by-Step Instructions. You're invited to visit the digital press kit, watch the trailer, and pick up a copy of the publication. It’s offered in digital and print formats.
The ebook (ASIN: B01FZ0JIIY) is available in:
- Australia,
- Brazil,
- Canada,
- France,
- Germany,
- India,
- Italy,
- Japan,
- Mexico,
- the Netherlands,
- Spain,
- the United Kingdom, and
- the United States.
The paperback (ISBN-13: 9781533370242) is for sale at:
- Amazon,
- Barnes & Noble,
- Strand Books,
- Harvard Book Store,
- Books-a-Million,
- The Booksmith,
- Hudson Booksellers,
- Savoy Bookshop & Café,
- Compass Books at SFO/Books Inc.,
- Books & Books - Miami,
- University Press Books - Berkeley,
- and other retailers and partners in the United States and around the world.
© Copyright 2018 Scott M. Graffius. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without the express written permission of Scott M. Graffius.